Taylor Swift and boyfriend Travis Kelce made news when their relationship went public. Although fans were worried Travis Kelce was using Taylor Swift to gain fame, the relationship achieved milestones, surprising many.

Despite the copious PDAs and happy news, the pair’s relationship is still plagued by whispers of rumors about their past relationships. One such rumor is Travis Kelce’s infidelity. However, Kelce’s ex-girlfriend, Maya Benberry, warning Taylor Swift of his cheating habits raised speculation about Taylor Swift’s being a cheater too.

Kelce’s ex-girlfriends have reacted differently to his relationship with Taylor Swift. Although rumors about Taylor Swift are entirely based on unsubstantiated interpretations of her song lyrics, fans argue that Taylor Swift is just as likely to cheat as Travis Kelce is. The Kelce cheating rumors are based on his ex-girlfriends’ comments about him, while Taylor’s new album The Tortured Poets Department also revealed how her last relationship with Joe Alwyn may have had something to do with infidelity.

Fans Think Taylor Swift May Have Cheated In Her Relationships Too

Some Taylor Swift songs talk about cheating in relationships, but hasn’t publicly made a statement

While speculations of Travis Kelce’s infidelity in relationships became widespread thanks to ex-girlfriend, Maya Benberry’s, accusations, fans noted that Taylor Swift may not be innocent either.

In a Swifties Subreddit room, fans speculate about her supposedly admitting to cheating or something close to it.

A fan wrote: “No, there haven’t been any cheating scandals with solid evidence, but she writes from the point of view of someone cheating an awful lot.”

There hasn’t been news or scandal, only rumors of her cheating on her boyfriends, but fans speculate that the songs “Gateway Car,” “High Infidelity,” and “Gorgeous” are all about her having emotional attachments to other men.

“It was the best of times, the worst of crimes…

I wanted to leave him, I needed a reason…

While he was runnin’ after us, I was screamin’, “Go, go, go!”

But with three of us, honey, it’s a sideshow

And a circus ain’t a love story, and now we’re both sorry…

— “Getaway Car”

“Getaway Car” from her Reputation album is about escaping with a new love, having been looking for a reason to leave her previous relationship. Moreover, the album was released after she and Joe Alwyn confirmed their relationship, which led fans to read more into the timeline of her relationship.

“The timeline is sus with Matty and Joe, and she’s pretty much admitted to cheating on the others,” a fan pointed out.

Do you really want to know where I was April 29th?

Do I really have to chart the constellations in his eyes?

You know there’s many different ways that you can kill the one you love

The slowest way is never loving them enough.

— “High Infidelity”

“High Infidelity” from Taylor’s Midnight album also talks unsurprisingly about infidelity. And from Taylor’s point of view, it was a love lost and knowingly and slowly killing the love her partner had for her.

Fans take the lyrics of her songs to mean admittance, but Taylor Swift has never addressed the rumors. She may have created a narrative for her songs, but some of her fans also think Swift never had exclusive relationships. “I also think most of her relationships were open/not exclusive,” a fan stated.

Nonetheless, Taylor Swift admitting she cheated in some of her relationships remains fan speculation.

Travis Kelce’s Ex-Girlfriends Don’t Think Highly Of Him

Two of Travis Kelce’s ex-girlfriends did not end their relationship with him on a good note

After rumors and confirmation of Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift began circulating, the dating history and personal life of the Kansas City Chiefs player was open to public scrutiny, including his dating history.

In the heat of his relationship with the “Anti-Hero singer,” Travis Kelce’s ex-girlfriend, Maya Benberry, was the first to throw a wrench at the budding relationship between the NFL star and Taylor Swift.

Benberry told the Daily Mail that Travis Kelce was a cheater and hoped Taylor Swift would be careful.

“Taylor seems like such a fun girl with a beautiful spirit, so I wish her the best of luck, but I wouldn’t be a girl’s girl if I didn’t advise her to be smart!” Maya said.

Benberry and Kelce dated for two months in 2016 after she won his E! dating reality series Catching Kelce, where she competed against 49 women representing each state in the US.

RELATED

Travis Kelce Only Agreed To A Reality Dating Show For The Money

‘Catching Kelce’ was Travis Kelce’s first brush with fame outside the NFL, but he didn’t really want to do the reality dating show to begin with.

“I’m sure by now she has mastered the ability to see who is really there for her – and who is just using her.”

Unsurprisingly, she pinned the cause of their split on Kelce’s cheating, suggesting he had cheated on her with sports broadcaster Kayla Nicole. The marketing expert said: “Only time will tell, but like the saying always goes, once a cheater, always a cheater.”

Another of Kelce’s ex-girlfriends, influencer Kayla Nicole, revealed what it felt like dating Travis Kelce, but did not disclose if he was a cheater or not. Nicole left a series of pointed posts on social media stating what it was like dating the Kansas City Chiefs tight end.

She wrote on Instagram: “Talking about ‘I want to see other people.’ Yea ok boy, pick your fighter.”

“I’m reminded that this isn’t just about me. This isn’t just my story. A singular experience. My truth, trauma and vulnerability are a relatable part of the human experience. I know I’m not alone. And I want to make sure you know you’re not either. On days when I feel most inadequate, I have to remind myself that I am, have been and will always be more than enough,” she wrote in another post.

While she clearly stated she had no beef with the NFL player, her cryptic messages made people speculate on the terms of their breakup. The insinuations point at Travis Kelce being the one to call the relationship quits and Nicole having to pick up the pieces.

Taylor Swift Talks About Joe Alwyn’s Alleged Infidelity In “The Tortured Poets Department”

Fans think Joe Alwyn cheated on Taylor, too

Taylor Swift’s The Tortured Poets Department broke streaming records when it was released on April 19th, 2024. However, what got people talking was the lyrics to her songs. Out of the 31-track double album, seven songs are assumed to be talking about her relationship with Alwyn and what went on between them.

Fans are speculating Alwyn was a cheater and also the reason Taylor Swift called it quits with him. The rumor was debunked, but after the release of the double album, it has surfaced once more, and fans point at the lyrics of some of her songs as evidence.

Joe was reportedly nervous about the album’s release, but fans shouldn’t expect a public statement from him anytime soon.

If Taylor Swift was not afraid to drag fans in The Tortured Poets Department, the chronicling of her relationship with Alwyn was not escaping the lyricist.

Fans theorizes the songs “Fortnight,” “Florida,” and “loml” push the narrative that Alwyn cheated. And when you have a lyric like this:

My husband is cheating

I want to kill him.

— “Fortnight”

It would only deepen the narrative that Alwyn cheated. Moreover, Taylor and Alwyn were engaged for years before their split, which could also mean “husband” is Joe Alwyn.

Regardless, Swift shared the vulnerable parts of her relationship with Joe in “loml,” including how she was ready for marriage, but he wasn’t. The heavy lyrics of the songs in The Tortured Poets Department only prove that the album is an ode to the heartbreak and loss she faced after her six-year relationship with Joe Alwyn ended and her subsequent relationship with Matty Healy fell apart.